Wednesday, January 12, 2011

It’s a bird, it’s a plane – it’s superman! It’s investment, it’s tax-saving, it’s a disguised insurance pitch!

Yesterday, there was another call from yet another persevering insurance company tele-caller.
The caller started the pitch for a very attractive investment product. Of course, the person was transparent enough to mention the name of the company, which had the word “Life” in it. However, the word “Insurance” following “Life” was conveniently missed out. So what, even Yudhisthir once said, “Ashwatthama is dead. Naro vaa kunjaro vaa!”
I entertained the caller and asked her to proceed with the features of the investment option. She started asking about my profession and date of birth. I asked her why she wants to know these details. Conveniently she proceeded to the next question. She asked my name, which I have no problem in giving. After some standard script, she mentioned about continuation of “free” insurance cover even after the investment term gets over. I insisted that I was only interested in an investment product without insurance cover.
By now, many of you know the modus operandi. The caller starts with the call. If the person on the other side asks too many questions, the call is transferred to a senior. The senior comes on phone and talks to me in a very authoritative manner asking what my requirement was – as if I called.
He had a very good answer for my point of an investment product without insurance cover. He said, “We are offering this small insurance cover so that your returns become tax-free.” Hello, is the regulator listening? Here is a standard pitch from insurance companies that they are selling an investment product (which is NOT a mutual fund according to IRDA). The insurance cover is given only to make the returns tax-free. These insurance companies do not want to change!
For how long will we allow such wrong approaches?
I haven’t taken the company’s name. Doesn’t matter! Those who practice such things, anyway know. Request to the poor investor, please do not fall into the trap of such calls.
Buyer beware!

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Is India fast becoming a seller’s nation?

We all have heard the great India story – one billion customers, growing wealth, increasing income, even faster increasing spending. Wow! How the hungry Indians have transformed into hungry for more! This is probably the biggest developments of the 21st Century. But this development seems to have come with something else. We are fast becoming a seller’s country.

I will share some specific experiences and for that I will need to take names. I can’t help it as real experiences have real companies with real names.

The other day, I had gone to pay my Reliance phone bills and I complained about frequent call drops. The response was very “matter-of-fact” – the person at the counter coolly told me, “Yes sir, GSM phones have that problem.” I also mentioned about the speed of internet connection (I have a wireless broadband connection), that in spite of having a broadband connection, I get the speed of a dial-up network. The guy was quick to seize the moment. He suggested I go for an upgrade to the newly launched 3G connection by paying only Rs. 2,600. He assured me that this connection can get faster speed.

This response prompted me to write this article.

These guys are trained to sell. Their performance is also measured in terms of sales numbers and not in terms of customer happiness or satisfaction. If you have a complaint, it will be logged into the system and then at a later date and time someone will get in touch.

The other leading mobile phone service provider – Airtel – is even better than Reliance. First of all, I have been a slave to the number that my erstwhile employer had allotted to me. So many people know this number; I cannot afford to change it. This is what the cell phone companies are banking on, probably. To their respite, the regulator also accommodated their lobbying (sorry to use this much-maligned word) long enough to introduce MNP (mobile number portability). My experiences with Airtel services are known to many of my friends and if I start writing all those experiences, it may turn out to be a small book. I would only like to narrate what is relevant to this article.

1. Go to www.airtel.in and what you’ll find is: if you are a customer with a problem and you want to find where and whom to contact, you will surf through the site and as the Ariel detergent ad says, “dhoondte reh jaaoge.” However, if you are an investor, you can simply click on a link right at the top of the home page. A single click on that link and you will be greeted by Mr. Mittal himself. The company is candid in telling us where the priorities are.

2. I lodged a request for starting voice mail services. Nothing happened for some time. On repeated follow ups, I was told that there is some technical glitch and company’s engineers are working to resolve that. After around 3 months, finally I was told that they do not offer voice mail services in Mumbai. With that I understood that the chapter was closed. One fine day, I receive a message that I had a message in my voice mailbox. Now, this is how I got to know that the service had started and that I was a privileged one to get it.

Tata AIG General insurance takes the cake. I had an insurance policy, which was renewed. I found that the renewal premium was higher by Rs. 3 from the previous year. Now, that surprised me. What the company had done was a stroke of ingenuity (however unethical it may be). They adjusted the base premium upwards such that the gross amount after Service Tax was almost the same as the last year, when the service tax was reduced from 12.36% to 10.30%. This 2.06% of service tax benefit was comfortably absorbed by the firm, without any notice to policy holders. When I followed up with the firm, the officers replied that they are free to revise the renewal premium without any notice to the policy holders. They agreed that they might have sent renewal notices with the old premia rates, but they were sorry about it (such a lovely word, this sorry is). I also got a written reply to my written complaint, where the officer started with "Let us explain ..." followed with no explanation whatsoever. A wonderful practical joke. Nevertheless, I had no time to follow up then and I gave up. When a year passed and the next renewal date came up, the call centre (sales) executives were quick to call up for renewal reminders. When I kept asking them about the status of my complaint, the calls stopped but were replaced with SMS messages that said, "we are unable to reach you ...". Someone had a very nice process of sending SMS when the customer is not available through phone, but the system was abused in case where the customer was insisting about resolving a pending issue.

I can go on and on, but let me not bore you with the details. I have such experiences with Nokia, HP, Dell, RCI, and HDFC; to name a few. When I share the experiences with my friends, I get to know they also have such issues.

What is surprising in almost all these cases is that the number of sales outlets is extremely high but the services centres are very few. The sales outlets are right on main roads, the service centres – you guessed it right, or maybe you already knew – very far off and generally off the main roads.

Is it suggesting something? Even at the cost of sounding too negative, I think, there is a message: dear customer, these companies seduce you as long as you are a prospective customer. The moment you purchase the product or service, you are not exciting.

In the process of getting more of everything and getting everything now, dear customer, you have lost a very powerful weapon of self-defense you had – choice. And the companies know that.

Rocket Singh – Salesman of the Year will always be in short supply.

Whoever said “customer is king” was dead right. Look at the kings in the democracy – by the way, I am referring to the erstwhile kings and not the Hindi of the word King (Raja).

Thursday, November 4, 2010

First impression

The other day, I was watching TV with my 4 year old son. The program was one of his favourite game shows. When one of the participants entered, my son asked me whether he will win. I did something I normally refrain from doing. I tried to predict whether the participant would win. I thought he would not and told my son so.

Later, I was replaying the whole experience and tried to understand what made me think whether the player would win. The answer was very simple and yet shocking. But before going to the answer, let us understand what one knew about the game. This is one of the game shows that my kids love to watch and hence I have also watched it very often.

My prediction was largely based on what I had seen of various participants – some won and some did not. One was trying to correlate certain “first impressions” with the player’s ability to win. And what does one see in less than half a minute? It is the body posture, the confidence – lack of it, enough of it or overconfidence, mannerisms, etc. – broadly a combination of body language and the appearance. And I knew the answer why I thought the participant would lose. His mannerisms exhibited arrogance and lack of seriousness. And I do not like arrogance.

This is what you call first impression. The mind judges through the first impression. It processes the immediately available information and jumps to a conclusion.

Well, what happened in case of the game show was quite harmless, but when decisions are taken with such biases, sometimes they may turn out to be very costly.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Mind blowing insurance product

Just got a call from an insurance company call centre. It was an amazing offer: They have a very attractive investment product. The investment component is also not invested in the stock market. They only invest in Government projects and will offer more than 7% p.a. compounded returns over a 25 year term. This is what they are willing to offer in writing. I inquired to the gentleman that how can they offer more than 7% p.a. when Government securities do not offer that much (net of expenses to be charged by the insurance companies). He said, that is where our company's expertise comes in.

After about 2 minutes of monologue (my question came in much later), the gentleman added another attraction. The product also gives life cover. Wow, This is now becoming too good for me to handle. Life cover coming from an insurance company. And all along I thought this call was from an investment company - how stupid of me!

I was pleasantly surprised with the offer. Such a mouth watering proposal !

Unfortunately, I was too naive to not buy this product. God only can save me now.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Devil's innovations

My friend and a leading financial planner Gaurav Mashruwala loves to share a joke.
Once a news reporter interviewed the Devil. After a long interview, the reporter finally asked, “What is that one thing you did that makes you proud?” The Devil tried to circumvent the question and started giving round about answers, but such questions in superlatives (best, biggest, largest, etc.) are the most favourite among the reporters. He insisted and finally the Devil replied, “The nastiest thing that I ever created is the credit card. It has the potential to ruin many families. Before the inevitable comes, they feel happy using it.”
That’s the innovation called credit cards.
Gaurav’s joke ends here. So let’s start ours.
The news channel carried a story about the Devil’s interview. There were public debates about the interview and the merits and demerits of credit cards. Someone brought out a very interesting point. They said, the Devil did not think much as those sinners who do not have credit cards are spared of the punishment.
The Devil was requested to come for another interview. He obliged. In fact, he could not resist the temptation of the publicity that television gave him.
After a few questions, the interviewer came to the point and asked the Devil (referring to the credit card answer) that the same spared those sinners who do not have a credit card. That way, it fails the test to qualify as your best idea. What do you have in such a case? The Devil’s answer was very simple, “Ever heard of tele-calling? That is for those who do not have a credit card yet.”
Well, the amount of outbound calls are done by the tele-callers is increasing by the day. Time has come for the regulators to introduce “Please call” registry instead of “Do not call” registry as the same does not work. It also involves painful steps in registration, a wait period of 45 days (I fail to understand why that should take 45 days. What do the phone companies do in the wait period? Or is it the proverbial “last chance” for the tele-marketers?). If you get a call after the wait period is over, lodging a complaint is another ordeal. You, the harassed, need to remember the steps to lodge a complaint. How some people can make life more and more difficult – is a puzzle.
The icing on the cake is the attitude of the tele-marketers. The caller thinks that he or she is doing a huge favour to you by selecting to call you. God save us from such Devilish innovations.

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Cause and effect

Jinxed mobile no suspended after 3 users die in 10 yrs
London: A jinxed Bulgarian mobile phone number—+359 888 888 888—has been suspended after three users died in the last 10 years, the last owner being gunned down outside an Indian eatery in Sofia, a media report said.
The first owner, Vladimir Grashnov, the former chief executive officer of Bulgarian mobile phone company Mobitel—which issued the number—died of cancer in 2001, aged 48. There were rumours that his cancer was caused by a trade rival using radioactive poisoning, the Daily Mail reported.
The jinxed number was then passed on to Bulgarian mafia boss Konstantin Dimitrov. He was gunned down in 2003 by an assassin in the Netherlands during a trip to inspect his 500-million-pound drug smuggling empire. Dimitrov, who died aged 31, had the mobile with him when he was shot while dining with a model.
The next person to be handed the number was businessman Konstantin Dishliev. He was also gunned down outside an Indian restaurant in Sofia in 2005.
Dishliev had been running a secret cocaine trafficking operation. He died after 130 million pounds of the drug was intercepted by the police while being smuggled from Colombia. Callers now get a recorded message saying the phone is “outside network coverage”. PTI
Report in Times of India, Mumbai edition, page 24, May 27, 2010

The above item in today’s Times of India caught my attention. I do not know why, but it just happened.
But when I read through it, I found it really very interesting. The news item brings out one interesting characteristic of human nature – finding patterns. We have been programmed to find patterns and large part of our knowledge is acquired through this mode of learning. It is instinctive to us – Pavlov exhibited this through his experiment with the dogs.
In the above example, people saw the link between the phone number and premature deaths. However, a wise person would like to question the “cause and effect” relationship – 2 out of the 3 above were involved in activities where the risk of death anyway was very high.
As investors we often make similar mistake of linking two completely unrelated events and take our investment decisions. It pays to stop before acting on such “coincidences” and ask a few questions.

Thursday, December 31, 2009

MF bashing

Recently, I came across an (actually, I should say “yet another”) article bashing mutual funds. I am in no mood to attack those who write articles bashing mutual funds, but it is important that certain things are clarified.

Mutual funds are very easy targets for bashing. It is easy to find faults with the various practices and performance numbers. Any day you open a financial newspaper or a financial website or the financial pages of a mainline newspaper, you see some story talking about problems with mutual funds. Ever wondered why people love to hate mutual funds or ever wondered why no other industry gets so much “hate reporting”?

Well, that is because of something that psychologists call “availability heuristics”. Availability heuristics means that people make judgments based on knowledge that is easily available. The availability of information is actually the biggest benefit mutual funds offer. No other investment option comes anywhere close mutual funds in terms of transparency.

We will take examples of three areas from where mutual funds get the maximum attack: insurance, stock broking and PMS (or portfolio management services).

Let us start with PMS or portfolio management services. This is quite similar to mutual funds as both employ professional managers to manage their investors’ money. Both can be called “managed accounts” while mutual funds are “pooled investments”, portfolio management services are “separately managed accounts”.
• Often PMS providers claim their ability to get out of markets before a crash. They cite examples of mutual funds whose NAVs fell.
o I would like to draw the attention of investors that NAV data for mutual funds is available to the world on a daily basis, which allows one to track the performance on a very regular basis. The data for PMS performance is only selectively available.
o In the absence of NAV data, even a savvy investor cannot check performance over various periods, risks in the portfolio, etc.
o The calculation of NAV happens as per SEBI guidelines, which is in line with ICAI guidelines.
• The fee structure of mutual funds is extremely transparent. SEBI has guidelines for the same and the structure is constant irrespective of who the investor is. That for PMS is negotiable and can be different for different investors.
• Mutual fund portfolios are available on a monthly basis (at least the top 10 holdings). The portfolio disclosure in case of PMS accounts is another dark alley. It is difficult for a prospective investor to take a decision without getting in touch with the PMS provider.

Broking firms keep talking about their superior ability to find the future winners, those multi-bagger stocks. Here again, the track record is either not available (on a daily basis) or it is available only selectively. The broker makes money when you do a transaction – either buy or sell. It is in the interest of the broker that you are excited to make a trade.

Ah, that brings us to PMS offered by brokers – they claim to be interested in your benefit but the portfolio does so many transactions that the broking division makes lots of money.

And finally, insurance industry – the less said the better. Most are negligent and do not know that they do not know. Yes, there are some stars, some good insurance advisors. But remember stars can be seen only during the night, when there is darkness all around. Ask a few questions and the agents have no answer. Even many insurance company executives have no answers to certain basic questions and then they hide behind the regulations.

The only request to all the MF-bashers is to come to the level of mutual funds in terms of transparency, flexibility, affordability. Jesus said, "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone."

Whenever I have raised this issue with some players, the reply has been that these are not regulatory requirements. Well, I believe transparency, ethics, customer-centricity are some things that need not wait for the regulator’s order.

Next time ask your stock broker how much money has the broking firm made through the buy-sell transactions you made in a year. Compare it with the money you have made (or lost). Ditto for the PMS provider. But in case of PMS, please ask for both the portfolio management fees as well as brokerage. Ask the insurance advisor to explain the “tables” in plain simple English – or whatever language you are comfortable with.
I request all the readers that whenever you come across a negative article about mutual funds, try to find similar information about the other investment options. The transparency of mutual funds is a great boon for the investors. Use it for your gains.

Finally, remember to also check if the writer has any axe to grind by writing against mutual funds.

From my side, let me make it clear that I make money by doing training programs for mutual fund companies and investment advisors. If someone wishes to consider that as my “interest” so be it. I am only suggesting that mutual funds have done it – let the others imitate.