Transcript of chat about mutual funds

Equity investments simplified

How are equity savings funds different from monthly income plans?

In some of our earlier articles, we have covered various hybrid funds. One such category was the MIP or the Monthly Income Plan – a hybrid fund that invests predominantly in debt securities and marginally in equity. Such a combination offers stable, but potentially higher than debt fund returns over long periods.

In the last few years, a new variant has been introduced that works very similar to an MIP, but comes with a small difference. These products are known as the “equity savings funds”, popularly.

Click here to read more about these funds ...

__________________________________________________________________________________
The English translation of the article is as under:

In some of our earlier articles, we have covered various hybrid funds. One such category was the MIP or the Monthly Income Plan – a hybrid fund that invests predominantly in debt securities and marginally in equity. Such a combination offers stable, but potentially higher than debt fund returns over long periods.

In the last few years, a new variant has been introduced that works very similar to an MIP, but comes with a small difference. These products are known as the “equity savings funds”, popularly.

These funds are a hybrid of three portfolios, instead of two in case of MIP. The three parts of an equity savings fund are: equity portion, debt portion and arbitrage portion. The exposure to the debt securities is kept below 35% in these cases, to ensure equity exposure (combined between pure equity and through arbitrage positions) at all times is above 65%. As we discussed in case of the arbitrage funds, keeping equity exposure above 65% gives these funds the status of equity-oriented funds for the purpose of income tax. Due to that, the dividends from these funds are tax-exempt in the hands of the investor as well as exempt from dividend distribution tax. The short term capital gains are taxable @ 15%, if the gains are booked within one year. If the holding period is longer than one year, the capital gains are qualified as long term and hence such capital gains are tax-exempt.

This offers a wonderful investment option for the conservative investor – stable portfolio returns with high tax-efficiency.

However, one must keep certain points in mind about this portfolio.

1.     This is not a debt fund, but a hybrid fund, having exposure to equity

2.     The fund has net positive exposure to equity, unlike arbitrage funds, where open equity exposure is covered by derivatives. Such a net positive equity exposure means the fund can exhibit higher volatility than arbitrage funds.

3.     The net equity exposure may be higher than in case of MIP, such schemes could deliver higher long term returns with high volatility in the short term. The risk is higher.

Given this, it is advisable to consider these funds only if you have money to be invested for medium to long term periods. These funds are not suitable for short term investments. Given the tax advantages, these funds could be a better option in comparison to MIPs.

- Amit Trivedi

Avoid falling prey to insurance mis-selling ...

While IRDAI can nudge the sector towards better practices, buyers need to view this as an instrument that provides risk cover, not as a tax saving or investment product

Read my article in today's Business Standard below ...

Avoid falling prey to mis-selling of insurance

Did the markets go up 21% due to demonetization?

Amit Trivedi examines if the Nifty rise of 21% for the one-year period since the announcement of demonetization is a coincidence, correlation or cause.

Click here to read the article ...

What is Bitcoin and How does it Work?

Is Bitcoin a good investment? Click here to read on ...

What are arbitrage funds? When are these funds appropriate for you?

In the last couple of years, one category among the mutual funds has gained popularity – the arbitrage funds. It is important to understand what these funds are, how they work and what purpose these serve. One must also understand the risks involved in these funds. Click here to read my article published in Mid-day Gujarati edition.

___________________________________________________________________________________
The English translation of the article is as under:

What are arbitrage funds? When are these funds appropriate for you?

In the last couple of years, one category among the mutual funds has gained popularity – the arbitrage funds. It is important to understand what these funds are, how they work and what purpose these serve. One must also understand the risks involved in these funds.

We covered this category in our column on February 6, 2017 with proper example. However, we feel that there are a few misconceptions around this category that need to be clarified, especially looking at the amount of money getting parked in these funds. Many consider this as safe as liquid funds, with the benefit of lower (or zero) taxation.

Arbitrage is a strategy to generate returns due to the price difference between two different markets for the same (or similar) securities. This often happens between the cash segment and futures segment of the stock markets, on account of what is technically known as the “cost of carry”. This “cost of carry” is akin to interest charged for short term borrowing.

However, since the money is invested in stocks (at least 65% of the scheme’s corpus), the fund is treated as “equity oriented fund” according to the Income Tax Act. This means the dividend is tax exempt in the hands of the investor, as well as exempt from the dividend distribution tax. Capital gains are tax-exempt, if the holding period is more than one year. Even when the capital gains are booked for a holding period of less than a year, the same is taxed at a lower rate of 15% and not clubbed with the income.

This tax arbitrage is drawing a lot of money towards these funds. However, it is important to understand the investment before getting on to the discussion of taxation. The investment theory must precede considerations of tax and the investment theory would help one analyse the risk-reward trade-off.

First of all, let us make one point clear: as per the classification for purposes of income taxes, arbitrage funds may be classified as equity-oriented funds, but in terms of investment theory, these are alternatives of liquid funds. Hence, please do not expect returns in line with equity funds. These funds can generate investment returns very similar to those generated by liquid funds.

At the same time, while liquid funds invest in money markets and debt markets; arbitrage funds exploit arbitrage opportunities between two different segments within the equity markets.

Pure arbitrage is considered to be an almost zero risk strategy, since the prices converge on expiry of the futures contract. However, there is a possibility that the spreads widen before the contract expires. In such a case, there could be negative returns, temporarily. One must be aware of this.

Such short term negative returns may coincide with your parking horizon and thus, you may end up with very low or even negative returns, if you have parked money for very short periods of time. This only means that one should not treat arbitrage funds as a total replacement of liquid funds, but use these only when the time horizon is slightly long, say at least one month.

In spite of the risk highlighted, the arbitrage fund could be a good place to park your fund and enjoy the reduced taxation.

-       Amit Trivedi